A pair of Scots/Métis prospector brothers who lose their heads — literally — in one of the most remote wilderness areas in the world? Yeah, that’s a sidetrail I can’t resist.
From Fodor’s Travel:
Lured by reports of gold in the area, brothers Frank and Willie McLeod journeyed from Edmonton, Alberta to the Nahanni range in 1904. Traveling with primitive gear, they traversed hundreds of kilometers by train, boat, and foot during a numbingly cold winter until they reached Gold Creek. Their efforts were rewarded that year and they returned to their home in Fort Liard with gold in hand. However, not satisfied, the brothers made a second expedition into the Nahanni range in 1905. They never returned.
Nothing was heard from Frank and Willie until brother Charlie McLeod led a search in the park in 1908, where he discovered two skeletons at their camp on the river’s edge in a vast valley. Their heads had been severed and one man lay with his arm outstretched towards his gun, the blankets were thrown across his brother as if he had leaped suddenly from the bed, read reports. From that day forward, the valley has been known as Deadmen Valley, and the creek called Headless Creek.
Canadian folklorist Hammerson Peters* has written on the Nahanni and its mysteries, and offers an animated video on the McLeod Bros.
Here’s a piece on the multitude of deaths and disappearances in the Valley of the Headless Men from the esteemed MrBallen**:
*We’re going to see (and hear) quite a bit of Hammerson Peters in these parts. He’s done a whole lot of storytelling in the frontier/wilderness folklore vein. He’s also a woodcarver and a Métis fiddler.
**MrBallen is Jonathan B. Allen, a former Navy SEAL, wounded (nearly fatally) in Afghanistan in 2014. He has built a following of nearly 5 million viewers on YouTube, telling true crime tales of the dark and mysterious.




Matthew says
That’s a perfect frontier tale for Halloween.
JimC says
Right?
Matthew says
Right!
Would animals take the heads? I would assume that they would go for the more meaty torso. Though they may not have access to it if they are in a sleeping position.
John Bullard says
I prosecuted a murder case where a husband killed his wife and dumped her body in an overgrown lot. Feral dogs and possibly other critters took her head off of her body where it was found several yards from her body, so it could have easily been animals that removed the heads.
Matthew says
So it could have been animals.
Patti Jo Beal says
I am so glad you put this on my radar! I can’t wait to explore this tale. Hopefully they went quickly, all though it’s my understanding that your brain remains conscious for 13 seconds after a beheading. This is the very first piece of trivia I looked up on Google in the mid nineties. I actually had asked my pa if there was something he always wondered about but never knew the answer to, well, that was his question…
JimC says
How was that tested?