Frontier Partisans

The Adventurers, Rangers and Scouts Who Fought the Battles of Empire

Stuff That Works — S&W 686 .357 Magnum

March 29, 2015, by JimC

My S&W 686 .357 Magnum and its little brother in .22 LR.

My S&W 686 .357 Magnum and its little brother in .22 LR.

I’m a rifleman and a shotgunner by preference. If I had a pile of money, I’d have a fine collection of both. I’ve never felt that way about handguns. But a fella ought to be competent with all three guns, so I do a fair bit of work with my revolvers.

Yep, revolvers. Supposedly obsolete in a world of polymer-framed, high-capacity 9mm and .40 caliber wonderguns. Maybe. I’ll concede that carrying 15 or 17 rounds in a pistol can have its advantages, and changing magazines is quicker and easier than charging a revolver with a speedloader.

Do I need two-dozen rounds for self-defense? Probably not. Jeez, I hope not.

I’ll stick with my Smith & Wesson Model 686, 4-inch barrel .357 magnum loaded with 158-grain semi-wadcutters. Yeah, it’s got limited capacity, it’s heavy and it’s not readily concealable. But it hits hard. And it’s the pistol I’ve got. That and its little brother, a .22 caliber Model 617. Picked up that .22 for a great price, and it’s a lot cheaper to shoot than the .357.

My then-boss gave me that 686 when I took on the news editor’s position at my newspaper, more years ago than I like to think about. Cool boss, eh? Him, he’s a BMW-driving, German engineering kinda guy, so he shoots a Sig Sauer P228 .40 cal. and its .22 twin. I really like the Sig, always have. Wouldn’t mind having one.

But if I’m gonna spend close to $1k on a firearm, I’m gonna by a CZ 550 FS rifle.

So I’ll stick with the one I’ve got — it’s Stuff That Works.

Filed Under: On Your Own Hook

Previous Post: « Massacre at Goliad
Next Post: Epitaph »

Comments

  1. Lane Batot says

    April 2, 2015 at 6:01 am

    I really don’t know much about firestix, but that sure is some nice clean carpet yer displaying them on!

    Reply
  2. Steve Bodio says

    April 4, 2015 at 10:39 pm

    I vacillate between 44 and 38 (357) cal revolvers (ALWAYS have a blue “Kit” model in 22) but they are all always Smiths!

    Reply
    • JimC says

      April 5, 2015 at 7:25 am

      Yep — robust, accurate and easy shooters. Back in the day some of my friends were big into the Colt Python, but I never shot it as well as the S&W 586/686. And the blueing was just too pretty.

      Reply
  3. Brian Hessling says

    September 11, 2015 at 6:43 pm

    I like wheelguns in general, but also 1911’s and Browning Hi Powers. Not a huge fan of polymer frame stuff. I do like this blog, which i just discovered today. Very cool…

    Reply
    • JimC says

      September 12, 2015 at 12:04 am

      Welcome Brian. Thanks for stopping by.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Frontier Partisans

  • Introduction
  • Jim Cornelius
  • Trading Post
  • The Muster (Links)
  • Search this Site

Podcast Campfire Sparked

Introduction to the Podcast,
or head on over to listen:
Frontier Partisans Podcast

The Trading Post is OPEN

Frontier Partisan t-shirt: Balen-Powell's illustration of Frederick Burnham on front; "The only partisanship we tolerate in these parts is Frontier Partisanship" on back.

Trading Post Cart

Cart is empty $0

Support Frontier Partisans

What I’m Aiming For

Go Fund Me

go fund me frontier partisans

Receive Frontier Partisans Posts Via Email

Categories

  • Chapters
  • Frontier Partisan Bookshelf
  • On Your Own Hook
  • The War Chest

Recent Posts

  • Britain’s Hard Man — Banastre Tarleton At War
  • The Sullivan Expedition
  • A Firefight In The Woods
  • Working The Trapline – An Iconic Rifle; Pirate Shanties; The First Mountain Man
  • The Way Of The Gun
  • Working The Trapline — On the Trek; Dark Horses; Counterinsurgency
  • North To Alaska
  • Working the Trapline — Deerslayer; Jungle Stories; Tiger Stripe; Stealth Camping & A Revolution

fp@frontierpartisans.com

© 2026 FRONTIER PARTISANS, Jim Cornelius