We told him about how our land had been stolen and our people were dying. When we finished he shook our hands and said, “endeavor to persevere!” They stood us in a line: John Jumper, Chili McIntosh, Buffalo Hump, Jim Buckmark, and me – I am Lone Watie. They took our pictures. And the newspapers said, “Indians vow to endeavor to persevere…”
We thought about it for a long time, “Endeavor to persevere.” And when we had thought about it long enough, we declared war on the Union.”
— Lone Watie. Cherokee. The Outlaw Josey Wales
Chief Dan George played the character of a Cherokee Confederate named Lone Watie with trail-worn gravitas and sly humor in the classic 1976 Western The Outlaw Josey Wales. Lone Watie was a fictional character created by the troubled, complex storyteller Forrest Carter — an anti-statist admirer of guerrilla fighters and the Cherokee people. Among other things.
Lone Watie was supposed to be a cousin of Stand Watie. Lone may have been a storyteller’s creation, but Stand Watie was the real deal — a Cherokee Confederate, tribal chieftain, leader of the 1st Cherokee Mounted Rifles, and one of the most successful hit-and-run raiders of the Civil War. He was the only Native American Confederate general in the war and would be the last Confederate general to surrender.
The Cherokee were riven by their own Civil War, with a significant faction wanting to stay neutral in the white man’s conflict, and another throwing in their lot with the Confederacy, in order to protect their autonomy from the federal government — and to protect slavery. Many members of the Five Civilized Tribes were slaveholders.
The neutral Cherokee were ultimately pushed into siding with the Union, and the 2nd Cherokee Mounted Rifles swapped sides in the middle of the fight — the only unit to defect wholesale to the other side in the Civil War. They became a Home Guard unit in Kansas.
The tale of the Civil War in Indian Territory will certainly be woven into my explorations of irregular warfare in that conflict. The Trans-Mississippi West — long treated as an irrelevant sideshow —has garnered a lot more attention in recent decades. It was, of course, far from the cockpit of the titanic struggle in Northern Virginia and in Tennessee and Georgia, but the Trans-Mississippi mattered. It is important to always bear in mind that the catalyst for the War was the future of the West.
And, hell, It’s an intrinsically compelling story, replete with extraordinarily colorful figures acting in a swirl of ideology and self-interest.
The Indian soldiers in the Civil War were Frontier Partisan warriors, heirs to a style of warfare that dated back into the 18th Century and carried forward into America’s first modern war.






Quixotic Mainer says
Great article! I believe the Union had at least one Native American general as well, Ely Parker was a Seneca and was a member of Grant’s staff.
I’ve always really enjoyed the western campaigns in the Civil War. The further away from the constant industrial feed of men and material you got, the more personal and digestible the conflict gets. Away from the seats of power something like Glorietta Pass was a campaign ending battle, while it would have only been a momentary delay had it happened in Virginia.
JimC says
You are correct re Parker — he was breveted a brigadier. Corrected the text to reflect that Watie was the only Native American Confederate General. Thx.
Agree re scale. The Trans-Mississippi theater is also most resonant in the way that it illustrates how civil society breaks down. There’s a great 1861 quote from a Missouri Unionist, the son of Lincoln’s attorney general to the effect that the war in Missouri would be nasty because neighborhood beefs and personal feuds would be overlayed by the conflict and lead to “social war.” I think that has a lot of resonance in these tumultuous times.
Quixotic Mainer says
Regarding personal feuds and exasperations drawing folks in on both sides til a full scale war is afoot, you’re absolutely right. I’m listening to “Thunder in the Mountains,” which follows O.O Howard, Chief Joseph and the Nez Perce war, (it’s quite good if you haven’t read it). The combatants there were often fighting men they had known, traded with and alternately loathed or liked.
Like you said, there’s a lesson there, albeit a grim one.
Matthew says
The comic Two Moons is about a Pawnee (I think it was) soldier in the Civil War and encountering supernatural entities. It was a good, but not great comic.
deuce says
One of my ancestors had to chase horse thieves into Indian Territory. They were Confederates who’d stolen the horses immediately after the Battle of Wilson’s Creek. He brought back the horses and got a commendation.
JimC says
Figured you had some ancestors in the fray in these parts.
patrulje says
My wife put “endeavor to persevere” on her response block to last years eval. A co-worker understood, but her boss was clueless.
JimC says
Oh, man, that is perfect.
Andrew says
I was going to use “the horrors persist, but so do I” on my next eval. “Endeavor to persevere” might be a less antagonistic choice.
JimC says
I spit coffee on my keyboard…
Jeff N says
Yes, a very informative article. Clint Eastwood/Josey Wales, Chief Dan George/Lone Watie, John Vernon (?)/lied to by the senator (what’s new?) and the others are my kind of people. Had I lived then I would have been with them while help to expedite the Missouri Boat Ride. The Civil War (still known as ‘The War Between the States’ in what’s left of the real South) is some of my favorite American History. Riveting but sad. I have 5 known relatives that served in the Union Army. Most if not all enlisted in Fairmont in the then Virginia which became Fairmont, West Virginia. Sure do miss them all.