The Frontier Partisans bookshelf is groaning under the load of new books from 2016 that are right in the wheelhouse. This year has been an exceptional one for really high-quality work — a new bio of Frederick Courteney Selous, and one of Frederick Russell Burnham; Paul A. Hutton’s magisterial study The Apache Wars (Book of the Year for me).
I just ordered a new one, which published in the fall. The first book I downloaded for my brand new Kindle Fire over Christmas 2015 was The If Man, Chris Ash’s biography of the South African Frontier Partisan Leander Starr Jameson. Ash is an apologist for the late Victorian/Edwardian British Empire, and it makes for most entertaining reading. Ash is very much on the side of the Pioneer Column in their smasher slouch hats and bandoleers, an admirer of the rogues and adventurers that mined the diamonds and gold of southern Africa and dreamed grandiose dreams about the expansion of an Anglo-Saxon Imperium. By Jingo!
You can glean a lot about where he’s coming from from his author bio:
Chris Ash grew up in the Shetland Isles and studied at Aberdeen University. After a brief and undistinguished dalliance with the British Army (Lovat Scouts and Gordon Highlanders), he drove his Land Rover to South Africa and decided to stay. Since then, he has worked in oil and mineral exploration all over Africa and the Middle East. His interest in South African history was sparked by watching Zulu and Breaker Morant as a child, ameliorated by countless drunken arguments over the years. He is a regular speaker on the remarkable life of Dr. Leander Starr Jameson, the subject of his first book, The If Man. His second book, Kruger, Kommandos & Kak, continues to fuel Boer War controversy. Away from work and history, Ash enjoys cricket, rugby, upsetting the politically correct, J&B and messing about in Landies. He commutes between Johannesburg and Iraq.
Ash is not producing measured, dispassionate history, he’s arguing his corner. It can get excessively tendentious, and I find his swipes at ace historians like Thomas Pakenham and Martin Meredith foolish and tiresome. I haven’t read his Boer War tome, but it’s generated its fair share of controversy. People tend to love it or revile it, depending on their tolerance for a pen-warmed-up-in-hell defense of the British Empire’s aims and conduct in South Africa (and, apparently, frequent groin punches to the Boers).
As long as you recognize that you’re reading a neo-triumphalist tally-ho version of history, there’s a lot to be enjoyed in the man’s work. Ash obviously truly loves the crazy-quilt assortment of imperial characters that populated the African frontier — a mix of gentleman-eccentrics, fevered imperial schemers and capitalists, prospectors and speculators, wild colonial boys and a seasoning of American frontiersmen seeking to relive an experience that was fading in North America. And to that I can relate. I love ’em, too, with all of their foibles and faults.
Ash’s latest covers The Matabele Wars of 1893 and 1896. Two of the Frontier Partisans I profile in Warriors of the Wildlands fought in these small but nasty conflicts in what is now Zimbabwe. I expect his usual vivid treatment:
Sandwiched between the glamour and heroism of the Zulu War, and the controversy and bitterness of the Boer War, the Matabele Wars of the 1890s have long been southern Africa’s forgotten colonial wars. There is no denying that the Matabele Wars are a lot less romantic and photogenic than the Zulu War. The wonky, unreliable Gatlings and ludicrous rocket batteries of the Zulu War had given way to the highly effective Maxim guns that were seeing major action for the first time. Nevertheless, the Matabele warriors showed every bit as much heroism, determination and élan as had their kinsmen in the Zulu War.
With oft-claimed links to the infamous Jameson Raid, the origins of the second Matabele War are as fascinating and controversial as those of the first, and it was a dirty, hard-fought guerrilla war, more akin to the African bush wars of the 1960s and ’70s than those waged at the height of the colonial period. The brutal murders of women and children committed by the insurgents and the widespread use of dynamite to entomb rebels in their subterranean hiding places both sparked fury and condemnation at the time, but aside from the butchery, actions such as the Mazoe Patrol were as heroic as anything of the age.
This is the first history, which covers both wars in a single volume, allowing the reader to see how they flowed seamlessly into one another and how they impacted on the southern Africa. Written in Ash’s typical no-holds-barred style, the book thunders along rather than tiptoeing round modern political niceties. Special attention is given to the many outlandish characters of the period: old-school savage tyrant Chief Lobengula, the ambitious and ever-scheming Cecil Rhodes, and the rascally Dr Jameson, of course … but also men like Captain Lendy, one of very few men in history to have died from putting a shot, Frederick Selous, the archetypal great white hunter, Kagubi the infamous witch doctor who whipped up so much trouble during the rebellion, not to mention the likes of Plumer, Forbes, Wilson, Colenbrander, Burnham, Baden-Powell, Gifford and the extraordinary ‘Maori’ Hamilton-Browne. Indeed, the cast is probably the most fascinating part of the tale: adventurous young Anglo-Saxons from every corner of the empire and a few old Indian fighters from the American West, who all found themselves thousands of miles from home facing a valiant and terrifying enemy.





deuce says
I wonder if Ash has ever shared a bottle of Scotch with Lawrence James? I’d wager the two would get on famously.
JimC says
Quite so.
Breaker Morant says
As others have said-Curses on you-LOL.
I was all set to read some Bartle Bull and maybe try a Hector Lassiter-Should I start with Head Games? “Apache Wars” was also moving towards the top of the list.
Now, I have to go down this path-Obviously, this jumps straight to the top.
I read an overview of the South Africa/Matabele stuff by Martin Meredith a few years ago-“Diamonds, Gold and War”-what I most liked about it was that it brought in the Mashona role in 1896 and I understand that better because of it.
I think it is good that we have some modern jingoes looking at this stuff. There is obviously no shortage of the anti-colonialist viewpoint out there and I bet Ash has a lot more fun than the dour academics do.
JimC says
I’d start with Head Games. I’m with you on the “modern jingoes.” There’s a lot of very one-sided anti-colonialist history out there — which is also worth dipping into in my view — but nobody is having as much fun as Ash is.
BTW, I downloaded a sample of the new “Breaker Morant: The Final Round-up” and will be giving it a pass. It’s just a giant research dump and a major slog. How do you make that story dry and dull?
Matthew says
I know Arthur Conan Doyle wrote a defense of the Boer War. I haven’t read it and don’t know enough about the Boer War to have an opinion.
I sometimes think it would be better if people just wrote what happened and kept their opinions to themselves.
Breaker Morant says
I will have to look at “The Final Roundup.”
At the library yesterday-I was holding both “The Apache Wars” and “The Earth is Weeping.” I made myself choose one and went with “The Earth is Weeping.” I am a little more of a Plains Indian guy but Apache Wars will be soon.
Also my Great-whatevers were involved in the Minnesota Massacre in 1862. They fled to a larger town and the Sioux stuffed hay into the house/barn and tried to burn them. One of the buildings did not burn and is actually still standing and in use as a garage. Still owned by another branch of the family and a large family reunion was held there in 2010 and I got to see it again.
On Apaches and prompted by your song ‘Once They Moved Like the Wind.” Have you ever run across the Louis L’Amour autobiographical tidbit that as a teenager he skinned drought-killed cattle in Texas with an old man who had been captured by the Apache as a young man?
JimC says
I had heard that anecdote. It really wasn’t all that long ago. The Fimbres incident was in the 1930s.
Gerard says
Hi,
I am reading Kruger Commandos by Chris Ashe.
It states that 546 Royal Irish Regiment soldiers were captured at Reddersburg. What happened to them. Were they taken somewhere and when were they released?
Regards,
Gerard
Dublin
JimC says
Thanks for stopping by Gerard. I don’t have an answer for you, but someone here might…