Frontier Partisans

The Adventurers, Rangers and Scouts Who Fought the Battles of Empire

Realizing A Vision For AMC’s ‘The Son’

March 21, 2017, by JimC

Adaptations of novels to film are a notoriously dicey proposition. The demands of film and print are different. A novel that has a devoted following is both a blessing and a curse — you have a built-in audience for a film adaptation, but they’re liable to be massively pissed off if you mess about with what they love about the novel.

Directors and showrunners bring their own “vision” to someone else’s material, and sometimes that vision is at odds with the original creation.

On balance, such adaptations usually disappointing and sometimes infuriating. Let us not go into the ways in which All The Pretty Horses was violated by Billy Bob Thornton, for example.

Sometimes the filmmakers and author are simpatico enough to make an adaptation that, if not literally faithful, remains true to the spirit of the author’s creation. Diana Gabaldon seems quite satisfied with Outlander, and the show certainly works.

It would appear that AMC’s The Son, which premiers next month, is one of that rare breed of adaptations that really works. In an extensive article in Cowboys & Indians Magazine, author Philipp Meyer waxes rhapsodic about the piece. That may be because he’s in it up to his hatbrim.

As an executive producer, co-creator, and contributing scriptwriter for the series, … the author remains well-positioned in the catbird seat when it comes to keeping the enterprise true to his original vision.

The Son follows a South Texas family from 1849, when young Eli McCullough is captured by Comanche raiders, through the early 20th Century, the era of the Mexican Revolution and the Bandit Wars on the border.

As in most deals that truly work, the creator has to be willing to stand up from the table, put his or her hat on and walk away.

Like many authors, he originally was reluctant to accept any alterations of his creation and cast a skeptical eye at anyone offering to turn The Son into a film or television series. As the novel first began to generate rave reviews and impressive sales, “I was approached by very powerful people in Hollywood. Some big, huge names wanted to do it as a movie. I got offered a dump truck full of money to basically just hand it over and walk away.”

But Meyer wasn’t so easily tempted. “I don’t live in Hollywood,” he says. “And I didn’t need a career in film or TV. ” Throughout years of negotiations and false starts, “I think what’s kept the project going in a way is I was always willing to walk away from any deal. Whereas most other people in Hollywood, when you’re adapting something, you’re not going to walk away from a project that has any chance of being made. It’s like shooting yourself in the foot.”

In the end, Meyer says, he was won over when Joel Stillerman, president of original programming and development for AMC, promised: “I want to make something that’s great, or it’s not really interesting for me to do it. If we fail, let’s go out swinging for the fences. Maybe we don’t hit that level — but we want to make sure that all of our resources are aimed at making something like that.”

But wait, there’s more: AMC agreed to produce The Son on location in Texas — the setting of the novel and, not incidentally, Meyer’s home state — even though it would have been cheaper to shoot elsewhere. The author was sold.

Yeah, I’m sold, too. It took me a couple of cracks at it to get into The Son, but that had more to do with my general loss of affinity with fiction than with any flaw in the work. I just don’t fall into a created world that easily anymore, much to my chagrin. I ended up listening to it on audio CD and liking it a lot. I’ll be programming the DVR and diving in on the show. I like the way it looks already, and now I like the way it sounds.

Filed Under: Chapters

Previous Post: « The Pulpy Goodness Of John Benteen
Next Post: Whiskers — From The Zapata Mustache To The Tactical Beard »

Comments

  1. Matthew says

    March 21, 2017 at 9:16 am

    Supposedly, John Huston when he adapted The Maltese Falcon (which was actually the third adaption) he handed a copy of the book to his secretary and said type up the dialogue and that was all to the script. However, some works are harder to adapt than others. I once came upon an adaption of James Joyce’s Ulysses. Of all things Joyce’s Ulysses! I didn’t watch it, but I can’t even imagine how that could be adapted.

    Reply
    • JimC says

      March 21, 2017 at 9:24 am

      Just… no.

      Reply
  2. Keith West says

    March 21, 2017 at 11:06 am

    Looking forward to this one.

    Reply
    • JimC says

      March 21, 2017 at 11:09 am

      The Bandit Wars stuff is right out of the history we explored through Bosque Bonito. I really need to do a deep dive into that stuff — the Pourvenier Massacre, etc. A lot of resonance with today…

      Reply
  3. J.F. Bell says

    March 21, 2017 at 12:51 pm

    “…but that had more to do with my general loss of affinity with fiction….”

    I’m wondering how common this is. Seems among people with similar interests as mine it happens more than I would expect, but as of yet none of us has quite figured out why.

    Reply
    • JimC says

      March 21, 2017 at 1:00 pm

      I’ve pondered it a bit. Some of it has to do with time — it’s just easier to pick up and put down non-fiction. I wrote my book with that in mind — it enabled me to write it, for one thing, and I’ve received feedback that people like being able to take it in manageable chunks.
      But I definitely have a greater resistance to giving myself over to a created world than I did when I was younger — something that goes beyond elements of time and distraction. I can’t put my finger on it either.

      Reply
  4. Dick says

    March 21, 2017 at 4:35 pm

    Pierce Brosnan???

    Reply
    • Lane Batot says

      March 22, 2017 at 3:24 pm

      Hey!!! Pierce Brosnan is GREAT! He does quite a few really interesting roles in films that I love, like “The Deceivers” and “Grey Owl”. He unfortunately has that inaccurate smarmy reputation that turns people off some of his more interesting(for us Frontier partisan types) films. Hence why I quickly jump to his defense! I also heard from a Local Casting director whom I got to know well during the filming of that epic cast-and-crew abuse film “Last Of The Mohicans”(where I was typecast as an uncooperative coureur de bois that didn’t follow orders very well), that knew Mister Brosnan personally, and said he was the greatest, kindest, least conceited big actor she’d ever met! And despite “Last Of The Mohicans”(1990) being NOTORIOUS in the business as one of THE WORST films to work on(I had fun, but then I was a coureur de bois that didn’t take orders very well…..), the end product WAS great!

      Reply
      • deuce says

        March 22, 2017 at 8:35 pm

        I’ve heard plenty of good about Brosnan as a person over the years myself. A pity he was contractually tied up the first time they offered him the James Bond role.

        Reply
      • john roberts says

        March 23, 2017 at 8:30 pm

        I talked to a guy who worked on LOTM as a French soldier. I asked him why nobody had bayonets. He said that there had been an aggreement that only experienced reenactors and members of the stunt men’s union would have bayonets or gunpowder. But they did a shoot of a night attack on the fort (excised from the final cut) and didn’t have enough extras so they went to local bars and hired a bunch of drunks to fill out the ranks and unwisely gave them bayonets and powder. The mayhem was what you’d expect: people stabbed, clothes set on fire by blank loads, etc. After that they just did awy with the bayonets. A great film, but perhaps not the wisest directorial staff.

        Reply
        • JimC says

          March 24, 2017 at 8:26 am

          Michel Mann has a certain reputation…

          Reply
          • Lane Batot says

            April 6, 2017 at 4:31 pm

            Don’t EVEN git me started about Sir Michael Mann! I was a snob Xtra on “Last Of The Mohicans”(I flatly refused to be a soldier Xtra–they wouldn’t let me be an injun extra–said I looked too “caucasion” er sumthin’, and they WERE NOT impressed with my bein’ 1/64h Comanche–so I was then typecast as a “Coureur De Bois”!) They had a lotta xtras, but did use the English soldiers to portray French soldiers at times–just switched uniforms! Those were REAL wool uniforms, too–one of the main reasons, in the Southeastern Appalachian August heat, I refused to be caught dead in one! I never heard the fetching drunks tale–I DID hea about the fellersr(and talked to some of those guys) that the local casting got from a local gym–seems they were having trouble finding halfway FIT xtras! I got to train with the 300 or so injun xtras, drummed up(ahem!) from all over the U. S. and Canada. We most assuredley trained with real muskets and powder, with a part Creek military guy–the neatest thing about my experience there! Since I got to hang with the injuns, I got treated better than the wretched soldiers–Dennis Banks and Russel Means who helped found AIM in the cast and probably had a bit to do with that! But was I EVER glad to be with the French injuns, as every take WAS a massacre of sorts–injuries every take, just about! I was actually IN the shot where the French and injuns stormed the fort after the surrendering English had left–it was a HOOT! But did get cut from the movie, alas. I never knew that anyone got skewered, but I did see when one guy’s back got broken when someone fell on him with a heavy musket(they airlifted him out of “massacre valley” with a chopper), and people got powder burns in almost every take of that massacre. LOADS(ahem!) of fun, IF you were amongst the French injuns, that is!!!

          • JimC says

            April 6, 2017 at 4:48 pm

            I love these stories.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Frontier Partisans

  • Introduction
  • Jim Cornelius
  • Trading Post
  • The Muster (Links)
  • Search this Site

Podcast Campfire Sparked

Introduction to the Podcast,
or head on over to listen:
Frontier Partisans Podcast

The Trading Post is OPEN

Frontier Partisan t-shirt: Balen-Powell's illustration of Frederick Burnham on front; "The only partisanship we tolerate in these parts is Frontier Partisanship" on back.

Trading Post Cart

Cart is empty $0

Support Frontier Partisans

What I’m Aiming For

Go Fund Me

go fund me frontier partisans

Receive Frontier Partisans Posts Via Email

Categories

  • Chapters
  • Frontier Partisan Bookshelf
  • On Your Own Hook
  • The War Chest

Recent Posts

  • Authenticity & Humility
  • On Heritage & Giving Thanks
  • The Diary Of Spencer Dutton
  • Working The Trapline — Highlanders, Paintings & Pumpkins
  • Trekking Out Into Cowboy Country
  • Conquering A Trail Challenge
  • Working The Trapline — A Firearms Revolution, The Return Of James Reece, Kings Mountain
  • Seminole Wind

fp@frontierpartisans.com

© 2026 FRONTIER PARTISANS, Jim Cornelius