Controversial Western Historian Dies

It shoulda been you, Josie.

Glenn Boyer died on February 14 at 89. He was a towering figure among those who mined the vein of Wyatt Earp history. For years, he was considered a groundbreaking researcher. Then cracks emerged in his work, a purported memoir of Wyatt’s wife Josephine and “Wyatt Earp’s Tombstone Vendetta.”

By the turn of the 21st Century, it was clear that Boyer filled in the gaps in his research the old-fashioned way: He made shit up. Or, “took liberties,” if you prefer.

And he was truculent and unrepentant about it. He claimed that his “Illustrated Life of Doc Holliday” was a hoax designed to trap gullible historians. Queried as to how that might affect the credibility of his other work he responded:

“I don’t give a damn about the credibility about the more serious work, let’s put it that way. Therefore, I have no idea how detracted the credibility…. Anybody that can’t tell, if they have read much of my serious work, that it’s bona fide is a candidate for mental examination. I’ve told the truth as I’ve seen it.”

(Boyer vs. Tefertiller: Penslingers Face off over Wyatt Earp By Sierra Adare, Wild West Magazine)

He sometimes claimed he was a literary artist, not a historian — an odd claim for someone purporting to write history. But Boyer’s stories changed a lot.

In 2000, Boyer and some supporters engaged in a tense confrontation with journalist, Earp buff and Boyer critic Allen Barra in Tombstone.

Boyer is responsible for one of the most widely reproduced misidentifications of photos in history. He put a beautiful, shawled woman with a singularly lush figure on the cover of “I Married Wyatt Earp.” Claimed it was a photo of Josie Earp taken in Tombstone. In reality, it was a photogravure titled “Kaloma,” from 1914. Sigh. It shoulda been Josie. It wasn’t Josie.

Boyer started out as a debunker of the results of the “print the legend” school of Western history, and ended up creating his own fictions — and his own legend.

It was all bizarre, colorful and larger than life. And kinda sad.

 

 

Comments

  1. John Cornelius says

    I think that MSU is becoming so widespread (literature, resumes, “documentaries”) that some colleges and universities are offering courses in it. I made that up, so you don’t have to check it out. Thanks for the morning titillation, though.

    John C.

    • wendy says

      I have a large copy, in a beautifully ornate frame, of this Kaloma picture. It belonged to my paternal grandmother, bought well before the 1950’s, when I was born. My grandmother would be over 120 years old if she was still alive. I have often admired and wondered about the picture and since my father is now 90, he is giving away his belongings and those of his late parents.

      I found a 1970 Melbourne University (Australia) magazine with the photo on the front page and bought the book hoping to find out more about the photo but it was not referenced anywhere. Since then I have Googled copiously and finally found the photo today.

      I was disappointed with the controversy about whether she really was Wyatt Earps ‘common law’ wife since my grandmother was ahead of her time and perhaps obtained it because she was a bit of a Womens Liberationist in her time.

      Any further decisions made about authenticity, other than what I have found on Google from various sources would be most helpful.
      thankyou.

      regards Wendy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>